Home  ·   News  ·   Weather  ·   Sports  ·   Jobs  ·   Community  ·   Pics N Videos  ·   Station  ·   Marketplace  ·   6 on Your Side  ·   Contests  ·   Get Connected
Family Health · Health Check · Schools · Time Saver/Traffic · Gas Prices · Backpack Journalist · Mom to Mom · City Cams · School Closings · HS Cribs · McKnight Investigates · DTV
WOWT.com on Demand
6 On Your Cell
News, Sports & Weather
Information On Your Cell
Text ALERTS
Breaking News Alerts
Direct to Your Cell Phone
Daily e-News
News & Weather Updates
delivered via email
You Cast
Submit Your Pics
and Video
What's on 6
Your Guide to NBC
& WOWT Programming
6 News Features
On Your Side
Don't miss the latest On Your Side segments.
Family Health
Don't miss the latest from Family Health.
Product Recalls
Check for threats that might be in your home.
Heartland's Most Wanted
Catch all of Heartland's Most Wanted here.
McKnight Investigates
Catch all of McKnight Investigates here.
New Charity Raises Concerns Save Email Print
Watchdog group says most money goes for expenses, not to the needy
Email Address: sixonline@wowt.com

A | A | A

You may have seen the boxes popping up around town. A new charity wants the clothes off your rack to raise money, but it's also raising suspicion and questions.

Peg Schneider donates clothes like she buys them. "I'd like to know I’m getting the biggest bang for my buck.” So before dropping old clothes into a Planet Aid box, she collected details on the charity. "Make sure it's doing what you want it to do."

Planet Aid sells recycled clothes to fund programs in poor, undeveloped countries. A spokesman says nationwide, the charity earned $20 million last year, donating $5 million to overseas causes. The rest, $15 million, pays various expenses for collecting clothes that includes the highest salary of $100,000.

“We pay our people a living because we think they should make a living, but nobody's getting rich off these clothes, the profits are going to people who really need it," says Plant Aid spokesman Doug Bailey.

But a philanthropy watchdog group gives Planet Aid an “F” for efficiency, claiming that for every $100 raised, Planet Aid has $73 in expenses. And it's competing for clothes with local charities like Goodwill.

Last year, Goodwill received nearly 20 million pounds of donations. That's up 8%. So far, Goodwill hasn't seen any affects of the new clothes recycling charity that's come to town.

“Yes, I'm concerned,” says Frank McGree of Goodwill Omaha. “Obviously we need the material to fund our programs. If they continue to grow and ultimately did affect our quantities, then I’d be worried about it."

Though Planet Aid may be a worthy cause, Schneider says the charity isn't a good fit for her clothing donation. “It just wasn't clear to me where the money was going."

Planet Aid disputes the low grade by the national charity watch group. It does not provide assistance to any groups that help the needy in our area, but eventually, Planet Aid promises to donate money to charities which are chosen by merchants that allow collection boxes on their property.

More Stories
Officer Takes Ford Documents

Thefts From Heartland Churches

More Jobs Lost in Nebraska

Funeral Arrangements Set for Former ISU Player

Free Security Cameras to Help Deter Crime

Search for Missing Man

UNL Students Building Edible Cars

Fire Victim's Mother Headed to Trial

Post Your Comments
First Name:
Location:
Enter Comments: characters left
Email (optional):
Email will not be displayed on site. For station contact purpose only.
Read Comments
Comments are posted from viewers like you and do not always reflect the views of this station.
Posted by: John G. on Feb 10, 2008 at 01:32 PM
Planet Aid is just what it looks like a Scam to get some people Rich, using americans as the bait. Give to the locals, such as Salvation Army and Goodwill

Posted by: LLR on Jan 15, 2008 at 10:58 AM
Goodwill has gotten extremely picky lately about what they will and will not take, how it has to be packaged, etc. Plus the drop-off center in our part of town closed. Another good solution is AmVets...if you get one of their pink bags in the mail, just put your donations in that sack and set it out by the curb (or on your porch) on the date the envelope says they will be by. Outside of the work necessary to actually clean those closets and bag up the stuff, I've found this to be THE easiest way to get rid of unwanted clothing and household items.

Posted by: bob on Jan 14, 2008 at 09:25 PM
These boxes are also an eye-sore. I've seen bags of clothes laying on the ground next to them. If you are going to use them, at least take the time to put the stuff in like you're supposed to!

Posted by: PJ on Jan 14, 2008 at 09:23 PM
To jd who posted earlier...Don't throw your things out.. THere are plenty of places to donate to that do a better job than this one. Or consider neighbors, co-workers,etc, especially when it comes to kids clothing.

Posted by: Stacy on Jan 14, 2008 at 03:44 PM
I think it is because the boxes are right there, it is easy. Goodwill needs to make it easier to donate, and people will stick with who they know hopefully.

Posted by: Annette on Jan 14, 2008 at 01:48 PM
So what if they donate over seas. We're all human beings with needs. So many people here in the United States of American have the opportunity to succeed, but don't take it and run.

Posted by: Limbani on Jan 14, 2008 at 01:27 PM
I know this Charity organization called Planet Aid very well, it has projects in my country Mozambique, they have helped alot of people in Southern Africa. Bravo Planet Aid.

Posted by: Brenda on Jan 14, 2008 at 12:49 PM
Goodwill and Salvation Army is good, but I don't like the idea everything is donated and they still want so much. A person should visit New Hope Village Bargin Shoppe in Carroll Iowa. Everything is donated and Jeans are $2 dress shirts are$2 tshirts and shorts $1 and coats around 5 or less. Childrens are 50cents to a dollar. They obviously know how to run a store and make money and the turnover is incredable. The store is very busy at all times. This is where I shop all the time.

Posted by: M on Jan 14, 2008 at 12:39 PM
Twice a year my family donates all of our used clothes and toys to the Lydia house. I prefer helping by donating to an organization that gives (people don't have to buy) to those who need the clothes. I feel that there are people here in the United States that need our help before we can start to help other countries. Homeless families are my priority.

Posted by: Cathy on Jan 14, 2008 at 12:10 PM
I'm for keeping it in the US. You can bet overseas wouldn't be clothing us.

Posted by: jd on Jan 14, 2008 at 10:58 AM
This is terrible! I won't be donating my clothes to them. I'll just go back to throwing them away

Posted by: J on Jan 14, 2008 at 10:36 AM
We need the help here. Any credible charitable organization would put the needs of the people first before the expenses and the outrageous salaries. People don't work for charitable organizations knowing they're going to live well, they do it because they want to help. I won't be donating to them. It's the Sienna Francis house, the women's shelter, etc for me. That way I know what they're doing with items & money and they're actually using it for what my intended purpose is.

Posted by: D on Jan 14, 2008 at 10:23 AM
Looks like a business to make a profit, and not a charity

Posted by: Roxanne on Jan 14, 2008 at 08:32 AM
I'm with you Karen!!

Posted by: Pete on Jan 14, 2008 at 08:01 AM
This sounds like a rip off like united way.. Their head exect's make big bucks. There is goodwill and salvation army which the profit percentage is around 3%. Who cares about overseas problems...we need to fix the problems overhere and keep the oversea's people out of this country.

Posted by: Kevin on Jan 14, 2008 at 07:15 AM
One should always be careful to whom they donate. Law in this country imply that only 20% of money collected has to actually be used for the charitable purpose to qualify as a tax-exempt charity. Always do your research before giving to any charity.

Posted by: FED UP on Jan 14, 2008 at 05:50 AM
Hey people check out United Ways expenses, and the fact they ask the people to pay it back, they did my wife's family back in the early 1980's... Not all charities are what they seem.

Posted by: KAREN on Jan 13, 2008 at 11:25 PM
They donate all to overseas projects? Lets help out those here in our own country. I will stick with the Goodwill or the Salvation Army. What a scam. Every dollar for charity has 73.00 in expenses? Some opened this charity so they could be self employed.

Media Partners