Judge Unaware Of Murder Case
Judge Unaware Of Murder Case Save Email Print
Says teen would not have been sent to Boys Town
Posted: 6:17 PM Jan 12, 2009
Last Updated: 10:00 PM Jan 12, 2009
Reporter: Brian Mastre
Email Address: sixonline@wowt.com

A | A | A

An Indiana judge is upset she wasn't told the teenager she sent to Boys Town last summer was a murder suspect.

Had she known, she says 14-year-old Nevin Brooks never would have been sent to Nebraska. He was arrested January 5th by Boys Town Police for an Indiana murder.

Brooks will go before Marion County Juvenile Court Judge Marilyn Moores, the same judge who sent him to Boys Town. On Thursday, she'll decide whether he'll be tried as an adult or juvenile for murder.

Brooks was sent to Boys Town in July for specialized treatment. At the time, he admitted to taking part in three armed robberies. Court records show the judge did not learn Brooks was a murder suspect until charges were filed against him in late December.

The teen arrived in Indianapolis last Thursday night after Indiana law enforcement officers picked him up at the Douglas County Youth Center.

Brooks is accused of robbing 27-year-old David Hardwick outside his Indianapolis home last March and then shooting him in the temple in what's described as a random murder.

Court records show police arrested the teen the next day for a different armed robbery that happened a mile away. A month later, a bullet found on the 14-year-old appeared to match the one that killed the man.

Last April, Brooks' mother September Benson apparently identified her son on surveillance video using the homicide victim's ATM. But prosecutors never told the judge. Boys Town says administrators only knew about a robbery.

Prosecutors say they never told the judge about this murder case because investigators were still trying to tie up loose ends and that they don't make it a habit of telling judges everyone they're investigating.

At the time of Judge's Moores' initial decision to send Brooks to Omaha, he had already admitted pulling off three armed robberies. A spokesperson for the county attorney in Marion County, Indiana clarified why he faces two counts of murder for one victim since he was booked in Nebraska on two counts of murder.

Indiana files charges differently than Nebraska. It appeared Brooks was charged with two murders. Authorities say when he committed a robbery, he intended to kill the victim. The intent to kill brought a homicide-related charge. The actual killing brought a charge of homicide.

"He was placed at Boys Town from Marion County Court in the first place for some involvement in a robbery to begin with, then apparently they've discovered evidence and issued a warrant for him," said Douglas County Attorney Don Kleine. "Certainly it's very troubling to see a young person like this in trouble with those type of charges."

Brooks was placed by the courts at Boys Town on July 3, 2008 and had been in a specialized treatment program since. While there, his placement didn't include the traditional treatment in family homes. Boys Town treats abused and neglected children.

The news has been hard on Brooks' mother in Indiana. She says the time her boy spent at Boys Town helped him a lot, but the help might have come too late. "It changed his attitude about life," said September Benson, Nevin's mother. "And helped him to see he can do better."

In 2008, Indianapolis had 115 homicides.

More Stories
Woman Wounded In Drive-By Shooting

Bellevue Mayor Suffers Possible Heart Attack

Police Ask For Help In Finding Hit-And-Run Suspects

Driver Gets Probation In Teen's Death

Salvation Army In Need Of Supplies

Girl Rescued From Pool Improving

Suspect In Coach's Murder Pleads Not Guilty

Motorcyclist Killed In Crash

Post Your Comments
First Name:
Location:
Enter Comments: characters left
Email (optional):
By posting this comment I have read and agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy:
You must agree to the Terms of Service to continue.
Read Comments
Comments are posted from viewers like you and do not always reflect the views of this station.
Posted by: Anonymous on Jan 24, 2009 at 12:28 PM
Does no one in Omaha, believe in change? Or trying to help the youth of our nation develope the skills and learn that there is something better in the world? Many studies have demonstrated the effects of parenting, environment, and brain development on the psychosocial development of a child. Have you ever been put into a tuff situation with being given the tools to solve the problem? For many of our troubled youth this is the situation. Often times growing up not learning the coping skills needed to deal with a tuff situation or how to critically think about the outcomes of their decisions ie long Vs. short term effects. Luckily Nebraska is the home of a program which aimes to teach these troubled youth the skills they need to succeed life and make appropriate decisions. Various levels from intensive treatment for those with psychiatric Dx to family homes, or home visits from counselors. though it may seem at first it is a waste, use your critical thinking to look @ the long run.

Posted by: Cynic - to Katie on Jan 13, 2009 at 05:05 PM
Don't they all find Jesus when facing actual jail time? Doesn't really make one think it is legit, just an attempt to look remorseful and pitiable in front of a jury. I, for one, am not fooled!

Posted by: to Katie on Jan 13, 2009 at 03:48 PM
If u knew what a hoodrat was, girl please, he may be from the hood, something u know nothing about, I pray this young man finds Jesus.

Posted by: jj on Jan 13, 2009 at 11:04 AM
i hope that omaha's DA and police dept has it together,indiana seems to be lost.

Posted by: OmahaAnnie on Jan 13, 2009 at 09:04 AM
Looks like a hoodlum to me.

Posted by: Rich on Jan 13, 2009 at 06:09 AM
After 3 armed robberies that are known, throw mom in jail with the kid. nice parenting.

Posted by: Katie on Jan 12, 2009 at 09:58 PM
Wow! He looks like a great kid! Nice bandana- straight up hood rat!Thank god he's back in Indiana- we have enough trouble of our own....

Posted by: Anonymous on Jan 12, 2009 at 09:53 PM
Boys Town needs to ask more questions when the courts are quote "sending" kids in. There are many more children outside of the courts that need and want the quality help Boys Town provides. Of course it all takes money and come with expense. The risk, money and expense for Nebraska and Indiana citizens in this case appears to have been taken for granted rather than analyzed. Boys Town knows better.

Posted by: John on Jan 12, 2009 at 08:26 PM
The judge knew about the 3 ARMED robberies and still sent him to Nebraska. I think instead of worring about the death penelty in Nebraska, we just send all convicted muderers to Indiana instead.

Posted by: jr on Jan 12, 2009 at 06:42 PM
The person (attorney) responsible for telling the judge should be sentenced to jail. How can you fail to disclose that information? Once again, our Justice System protecting the law abidding citizens. What a joke! End his young life before he murders again.

Special Sections