Burned Handicapped Woman Locked In Room
Burned Handicapped Woman Locked In Room Save Email Print
Mom arrested, suspicious fire under investigation
Posted: 3:34 PM Jun 22, 2008
Last Updated: 6:54 PM Jun 23, 2008
Email Address: sixonline@wowt.com

A | A | A

An Omaha woman will be charged Tuesday with abusing a vulnerable adult. Cherie Harbour was arrested over the weekend after her wheelchair-bound daughter was left home alone and critically burned in a suspicious fire.

Firefighters called to the home at 65th and Maple Street around 7:45 p.m. Saturday were told by a neighbor that a handicapped woman, 23-year-old Tawnisha Harbour, was still inside.

She suffered burns to 30 percent of her body. Tawnisha was taken to Creighton Medical Center in critical condition, then transferred to the Clarkson Burn Unit where she is still being treated. An updated condition has not been released.

Neighbors are shocked by the fire and stunned by the arrest of Tawnisha's mother, 40-year-old Cherie Harbour.

"It would be hard for me to think her mother would do that," said Marvin Godbolt. "Actually, I would say iI have to see it, you know, just to see them come with some physical evidence or fingerprints is on there, the girl says, hey my mother put me in here."

According to the police report, Tawnisha was effectively locked inside the burning room. One door was tied shut with a bed sheet while a second door had a door knob on the outside, but not on the inside. The report goes on to reveal her mother was responsible for this.

"It makes me sick if that happened," said neighbor Michele. "To hear that, that's pretty bad," said Marvin.

Even after hearing what was in the police report, neighbors don’t want to jump to conclusions. They say on several occasions, Tawnisha locked herself out of the house and had to go to them for help. They think it might be a situation where someone thought they were actually helping Tawnisha by keeping her in that room.

"It gives me the chills really because, God I don't know about now if she did that?” said Michele. “You sure she did it?"

Investigators have called the fire suspicious, adding they are continuing to investigate and going through the debris. It appears the fire started in the room where Tawnisha was, but it has yet to be determined how the fire started.

"I was just hoping she was alive, hoping she was okay because she's a nice girl," said Marvin, who watched the fire with his mother Mertis from their front porch.

They've known Tawnisha for years. "The first person I thought about when I see the fire was I thought about her, thinking about her and how she's going to get out of there."

“They put the covers over her all the way because I thought maybe she was burned bad or worse because usually when they cover somebody up they might have passed away," said Marvin.

Raquish Harbour drove up to the house just after the fire started and watched as paramedics finally freed her sister. "It was crazy, what do you want me to say? Because it was our house and our sister and there wasn't anybody here."

“I would never have left a child of mine in a house by herself in a wheelchair in that condition,” said Mertis Godbolt, who has seen a lot from her front porch over the years.

"It's sad to know that she was in there by herself. This isn't the way you treat a young lady, no way at all."

More Stories
Family Mourns Loss Of Loved One

Man Critically Wounded by Gunfire in South Omaha

Fire at Omaha Apartment Complex Blamed on Electrical Problem

Ralston Celebrates Independence Day

Holiday Weekend Fireworks Displays

Man Drives Himself to Hospital after Shooting

Weather Cooperates For Fireworks Show

Fireworks Injury Victim Warns Others

Post Your Comments
First Name:
Location:
Enter Comments: characters left
Email (optional):
By posting this comment I have read and agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy:
You must agree to the Terms of Service to continue.
Read Comments
Comments are posted from viewers like you and do not always reflect the views of this station.
Posted by: Anonymous on Jun 26, 2008 at 12:44 AM
first of all don't none of ya'll know what ya'll talking about. It's irrisponsible to leave a handicap person in the house unintended any how. to make a run or anything that doesn't matter if u need to leave you take your child with you. All i'm saying is if your not fir to be a parent you shouldn't have children.....

Posted by: Jenna on Jun 25, 2008 at 04:17 AM
Who hasn't left a child alone for half an hr while they went for a quick grocery run, and locked the door from outside? Please people. Her daughter could have set the fire from that room. Oops. Didn't see that happening. Let's wait for more information before we are so quick to judge..

Posted by: jjj on Jun 24, 2008 at 12:29 PM
sounds like a budding group of crime novelists here - none of you know the story, so quit speculating.

Posted by: Ann on Jun 23, 2008 at 09:16 PM
To wow and all--Yes, given another snippet of info on the situation, I still feel terrible for everyone involved. Remember, you still have only a little bit of info, and I guess it is human nature to fill in the rest with our own view of the world. My many years of experience have taught me that we are nearly all more than willing to fill in the blanks with motivations and behavior of which we can't possibly be sure. We see events from our own narrow perspective.

Posted by: Dee on Jun 23, 2008 at 08:54 PM
She locked her in her room people! No one should be doing that. She & only she is responsible for what happened. End of story!

Posted by: wow on Jun 23, 2008 at 05:04 PM
Sweet...all you defending her. This is just like every other story--before the police are even given a chance to state their case we are all over it with our own version of what happened when we were not there. Now, given a few more details, you still feeling so bad for this mom?

Posted by: Whatta Sicko on Jun 23, 2008 at 04:40 PM
She should be put in a men's prison, and in the general population.

Posted by: More will be revealed on Jun 23, 2008 at 04:36 PM
Investigators said the doors to the room could not be opened from the inside because one was tied shut with a sheet and the other had no inside door knob.

Posted by: T on Jun 23, 2008 at 01:55 PM
According to police reports - "The doors of Tawnisha Harbour's bedroom could not be opened from inside the room. One door was tied from the outside with a bed sheet. The other had only one doorknob — on the outside of the bedroom. So when a fire broke out in her house Saturday night, Harbour, who relies on a wheelchair, had no way to escape. A police investigation revealed that Harbour's mother was responsible for "securing the room," the reports stated." Now someone please explain to me how this mother is NOT responsible??? Sounds to me like she is. She went to an awful lot of work to make sure her daughter (who is already disabled and can't get around without assistance) stayed locked up in that room. Her poor daughter couldn't get out even if she tried!! I hope the investigation leads to a conviction. The mother obviously knew what she was doing when she locked this poor woman up. Noone deserves that treatment. Keep Cherie locked up!

Posted by: Bob on Jun 23, 2008 at 01:40 PM
The paper is reporting that the two doors to exit the room were intentionally restricted.. one by a bed sheet tied to something on the outside and the other without a door knob on the inside thus making it impossible for the doors to be opened from the inside. I don't think the mom ever imagined that this act would harm her daughter, more than likely is was done to keep the person from harming herself in the kitchen or elsewhere in the home.. but nonetheless, this mom is going to be charged and convicted even if the daughter were independent able to care for herself for any period of time. Sad situation but hindsight is 20/20.

Posted by: Donnie on Jun 23, 2008 at 11:23 AM
Let's wait to hear the details before we judge this family. I have worked with cogntively and physically challenged individuals for many years. Many of these people can lead independent lives and do not require 24 hour care. Therefore it would be perfectly acceptable for this young woman to be left alone for periods of time. Again, I do not know the details so I am witholding judgement until I do.

Posted by: Curious on Jun 23, 2008 at 11:14 AM
To all of you people on here angry about this situation think about it, yes she was disabled but she was 23 and had a ramp to get in and out of the house. If you think that this person is so horrible than you better all post on the story about the 2 year old in South O that was found on the interstate, why are her parents not jailed and yet this mother is. The little girl in SO did nto get hurt, i will give you that, but jsut a few more steps and she is a 2 year old standing in the interstate, with Omaha drivers that are to busy on their cell phones, putting on makeup or just cutting off the car in front of them to probalby even notice her. Then you have a completly different story/tragidy on your hands.

Posted by: Edgar on Jun 23, 2008 at 09:52 AM
Guess we need to wait for the information on the cause of the fire before making judgements. Nothing was said about the level of incapacity the younger woman had. Being a caregiver can be devastatingly hard - I have seen it in a neighbor's family, but they had a family support system. We don't know that the mother set the fire or set up the circumstances, but maybe the daughter had some capacity to try to do something that ended wrong. Let's wait until the cause is announced. It is a terrible thing under any circumstances.

Posted by: Torri on Jun 23, 2008 at 09:05 AM
For the person saying her mom should not be responsible her daughter is disabled and considered a vulnerable adult so there for your saying the mother should not be responsible for leaving a child left home alone. also if she was not capable of taking care of her daughter or just did not want to she could have gotten help even if she needed respite while she runs errands or just a few days to her self.

Posted by: S on Jun 23, 2008 at 09:01 AM
To Anonymous: That is a pretty long limb, are you familiar with the family or situation? To Dave: Aren't we quite high and mighty? Both of you have read quite a bit into this five minute news story.

Posted by: Bob on Jun 23, 2008 at 08:29 AM
Hmmm, this story has me dazed & confused. To say that the mom is negligent for leaving a 23 yr old wheelchair bound adult alone is questionable at best. I'm going to comment strictly on the caregive/liability situation without having any details to say how this fire was started. To say that this mother should be with this adult 24/7 is ridiculous unless we know the extent of the persons handicap. My sister-in-law is confinded to a wheelchair due to cerebal palsy and lives alone, she's 50 yrs. old. Are you telling me that if something happens to her that her family is liable b/c she lives alone? It doesn't work that way. Her body may be physically derailed but her mind isn't, she is an independent and stubborn woman. I don't know the extent of Tawnisha's condition but it would seem it is also physical.. in which case she could independently stay alone for short periods of time. Let's not rush to judgment and assume that mom isn't entitled to a night out! I pray for all of them!

Posted by: Terry on Jun 23, 2008 at 07:57 AM
Unless you have cared for an individual who is not able to care for themself you have no idea what it is like. No one should be judging this woman. Yes leaving her alone was wrong, but I doubt she set the fire. If you what to judge walk in her shoes for a day.

Posted by: Anonymous on Jun 23, 2008 at 07:41 AM
so...why is mom the one that got booked...why not dad or someone else who could have been in charge of her?

Posted by: Jill on Jun 23, 2008 at 07:32 AM
I can't imagine what it is like caring for a handicapped child. It would be tough to never leave them alone if you have to run an errand or something. Now if the fire is suspicious that is a whole different story.

Posted by: Anonymous on Jun 22, 2008 at 11:33 PM
Of course the fire is being considered suspicious! I'm going to go out on a limb here and say the mother, tired of having to care for her daughter, probably set the fire in hopes her daughter would die. Pathetic. And why was the sister smiling when being interviewed? The whole thing is just so sad!!!!!

Posted by: Shelly on Jun 22, 2008 at 10:52 PM
Why is family held but if paid staff in home or a facility is harming a disabled nothing is ever done. W/C's are not easy to get around like packing up a baby. what was she to do. We all know quality care for a disabled is non-existant whether it be in a care facility or by a home health care agency..Circumstances need to be looked at here. If the state was to provide services why did't they help that mother obtain it?

Posted by: Ann on Jun 22, 2008 at 10:45 PM
I also know Tawnisha, and what has happened to her is horrifying. But it is so easy to be angry with the mom or other family members. Most people, including myself, do not know what it is like being responsible for someone disabled and in a wheelchair for nearly five years. We don't know anything except for the small amount of info in the news. When it comes to casting the first stone, I believe I will have to acquiesce to those who are without sin.

Posted by: Jeff on Jun 22, 2008 at 10:45 PM
Another trifflling individual.She's up there with that guy who tried stealing items from the flood victims in Iowa

Posted by: Anonymous on Jun 22, 2008 at 09:56 PM
I know this handicap girl from maple crest so sad. hope she pulls through

Posted by: mom on Jun 22, 2008 at 09:51 PM
Its sad that something terrible happened to this girl. There are probably a lot of details left out and a lot of unanswered questions like why wasnt the sister arrested? why is this mother 100 % responsible for her daughter who is 23-years-old? Its not like this person was a minor. You take care of your child because you want to, not because by law you have to. I think more than one person is to blame for this disabled young woman, not just the mother. Maybe she was able to be left alone while her mother shopped for food or clothing for her daughter. Dont judge until we know the whole story.

Posted by: Anonymous on Jun 22, 2008 at 06:52 PM
It's sad that the home wasn't equipped such that the daughter could leave ... just open the door and roll down a ramp.

Posted by: Dave on Jun 22, 2008 at 05:43 PM
Take her child away,never let her have custody again. And require her to be "fixed" so she may never ever pro-create again! And sorry for insulting any dogs out there for using the term "fixed" but she deserves no better term of what should be done to her!

Posted by: ben on Jun 22, 2008 at 05:39 PM
WHAT WAS THE MOM OUT CELEBRATING HER BIRTHDAY?

Special Sections